Home Makeup 7 Best Eyebrow Pencils For Redheads In 2022

7 Best Eyebrow Pencils For Redheads In 2022

by Gabbi

The best eyebrow pencils for redheads exist but they’re difficult to find.

If you’re a ginger, you know the struggle is real when it comes to finding a good pencil that matches your eyebrows perfectly. However, we combed the market, so you don’t have to!

So what are the best eyebrow pencils for redheads? We recommend buying a shade that looks the most natural on you. There are plenty of color options, including camel, honey, reddish-brown, auburn, and more. The best looking eyebrow pencil will be one that complements your natural eyebrow color.

Without further ado, let’s review the best brow pencils for redheads.

Buying Guide: Best Eyebrow Pencils for Redheads

What color should you choose for your eyebrows? Here’s a quick guide to choosing the right shade:

  • If you have light red hair, opt for eyebrow items in ginger, camel, honey, or golden-red tones.
  • If your hair is medium red, pick a reddish-brown, reddish-taupe, or burnt sienna shade.
  • People with dark red hair should focus on deep reddish-brown, auburn, or dark brown colors for their eyebrows.

When shopping for eyebrow pencils, always consider your hair color. Also, rather than choosing a brow shade that’s a clear match with your hair, try utilizing a shade lighter or even darker.

If you have light red hair, try dark blondes and taupes. Too ashy of a brow can cause your skin to appear sallow. Opt for a slight warmth to the blonde to keep a natural and elegant appearance.

People with dark red hair should consider dark brown and auburn shades for eyebrows. It’s important to fill in and shape your eyebrows naturally, not dramatically, according to beauty gurus.

The Best Eyebrow Pencils for Redheads

Finding the right eyebrow pencil can be easy for everyone else, except for redheads. Luckily, we found 7 of the best eyebrow pencils that work well for redheads and provide flawless results. 

RankEyebrow PencilShadeBest For
1.Anastasia Beverly Hills Perfect Brow PencilCaramel or AuburnStrawberry blonde hair or reddish-taupe hair
2.Jane Iredale Retractable brow pencilBrunette or medium brunetteAuburn or strawberry blonde
3.Haus Laboratories The Edge Precision Brow PencilCinnamon or auburnLight red and strawberry blonde or auburn
4.Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer PencilBlondeStrawberry blonde hair
5.NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow PencilTaupe or AuburnReddish-taupe hair or auburn hair
6.L'Oreal Paris Ultra-Fine Waterproof Eyebrow PencilDark BlondeCopper-toned hair
7.Revlon ColorStay Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie BrushAuburnAuburn hair
8.Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow PencilAuburnReddish-brown hair
9.Wet n Wild Color Icon Brow PencilGinger RootsGolden-red hair

1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Perfect Brow Pencil

Check Current Price on Amazon

Last but not least, Anastasia Beverly Hills brow pencil deserves a spot on this list because it’s perfect for redheads and light-colored hair. It’s also pricey but it’s worth the cost.

This pencil has a wax-based formula on one end for filling in and shaping the eyebrows and a brush on the other end for effortless blending. The pencil goes on smoothly and lasts for hours.

The best part? You will end up with natural-looking brows with a matte finish. You will adore this pencil. It’s simple to utilize and provides maximum control. It comes in eight different shades.

Anastasia Beverly Hills has a fine point for precise filling. However, it’s not self-sharpening. The auburn color is one of few true auburn pencils available and it goes on so well.

Best For:

  • The Caramel color is best for strawberry blonde hair
  • The Auburn color is best for reddish-taupe hair

Key Features:

  • Long-lasting and matte finish
  • Performs better than regular eyebrow pencils
  • An excellent choice for redheads

2. Jane Iredale Retractable Brow Pencil

Check Current Price on Amazon

This retractable brow pencil from Jane Iredale comes in two shades with red undertones, “brunette” and “dark brunette.” Don’t be fooled by the names – these shades are perfect for defining and filling light to dark red brows, respectively.

The formula blends seamlessly with your brows to create a flawless and natural finish that won’t look blocky, patchy, or overdone.

The retractable tip eliminates the need for sharpening and helps you avoid making a mess on your vanity table, while the spoolie will allow you to comb your brows into submission to create your perfect shape.

Best For:

  • “Brunette” (actually red) is best for strawberry blonde to light red hair
  • Dark “brunette” (rich red-brown) is best for auburn hair

Key Features:

  • Retractable
  • Spoolie side
  • 2 shades with red undertones
  • Precision tip
  • Medium coverage for natural hairs to show through

3. Haus Laboratories The Edge Precision Brow Pencil

Check Current Price on Amazon

We’re sure you’ve heard of Lady Gaga’s Haus Laboratories brand before, and not just because she’s a super star – her products alone are to die for!

This eyebrow pencil has a buttery smooth formula that easily glides across your brows without leaving any gaps or clumps.

With a retractable precision tip, you’ll be able to draw realistic hair-like strokes for a perfectly natural finish without having to constantly sharpen it.

This formula is designed for all-day wear as well, so you won’t have to reapply throughout the day. Just use the convenient spoolie end to brush your hairs into place, draw your strokes with the precision tip, fill in the gaps, and viola!

Perfect brows all day long!

Best For:

  • Cinnamon is best for strawberry blonde to light red hair
  • Auburn is best for traditional red hair

Key Features:

  • Spoolie
  • 2 red shades
  • Retractable
  • Precision tip
  • Effortless application and blending

4. Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil

Check Current Price on Amazon

The Maybelline Total Temptation eyebrow pencil has been purchased by many people over the years. This pencil can fill in your eyebrows with the teardrop tip effortlessly and perfectly.

First, define your brow with the eyebrow brush for a softly defined natural-looking eyebrow. Then, fill in your eyebrows with Maybelline’s micro eyebrow pencil for filled softly defined eyebrows. 

Whatever your signature eye look, dramatic or natural, this eyebrow pencil helps you achieve your goal. Maybelline has a wide selection of highly-pigmented, liquid eyeliners, and eyebrow pencils.

They also have top-quality eyeshadows and mascaras. Maybelline is a trustworthy company that never disappoints. Their eyebrow pencil is available in different shades suitable for redheads.

Best For:

  • The Blonde color is best for strawberry blondes

Key Features:

  • Perfect tip and amazing color
  • The length of the pencil itself makes it very manageable
  • The best retractable brow pencil


Check Current Price on Amazon

Another eyebrow pencil that works great for redheads is NYX professional makeup micro brow pencil. It provides beautiful natural-looking results thanks to the super skinny tip.

You can shape, define, and fill your eyebrows with this pencil. It works perfectly for over-tweezed brows and delivers a natural-looking finish. It easily creates the appearance of natural brow hairs.

Up your eyebrow game with NYX professional makeup brow pencil and other high-quality products. NYX is a popular company with a broad selection of brow markers, brow pencils, and brow gels.

They also have dip eyebrow powder for different eyebrow looks. The best part? They’re cruelty-free and acknowledged by PETA as cruelty-free products. NYX doesn’t test on animals.

Best For:

  • Both the Auburn and Taupe colors are great for auburn hair (depending on your exact shade)

Key Features:

  • Vegan formula
  • Lightweight, all-day hold
  • Smooth and even application
  • Naturally-defined brows
  • Micro-precise tip

For a full tutorial on the Auburn color from NYX MicroBrow, watch this video by BethanyFae. Enjoy!

6. L’Oreal Paris Ultra-Fine Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

Check Current Price on Amazon

The L’Oreal Paris ultra-fine pencil is a waterproof eyebrow tool with a self-sharpening tip. With the help of this pencil, you can fill in sparse gaps or areas and play with different styles.

This eyebrow pencil provides flawless, natural-looking eyebrows. But here’s the kicker. The mechanical tool is ophthalmologist tested and suitable for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes.

What we like most about this pencil is that it’s waterproof and long-lasting. L’Oreal is a trustworthy and well-known brand with a variety of makeup including smudge-proof eyeliners with shades for every eye color. You can pair this high-quality eyebrow pencil with their volume building mascara.

It comes in different shades including shades for blondes and redheads. The best part? It’s affordable! If you’re looking for a budget-friendly brow pencil, look no further than this product.

Best For:

  • The Dark Blonde color is best for copper-toned hair

Key Features:

  • It’s easy to apply and lasts all-day
  • The color is perfect and looks natural
  • The small brush is ideal for prepping

7. Revlon ColorStay Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie Brush

Check Current Price on Amazon

The Revlon ColorStay eyebrow pencil includes a brush for grooming hairs in place. It also has a precise angled tip to precisely fill the eyebrow.

The dual-ended pencil can help you soften the color and achieve a natural-looking brow. The reason why we chose this pencil is that it’s waterproof and long-lasting.

According to satisfied buyers, this pencil lasts up to 24 hours! The best part? It’s available in many colors so you can easily find the shade for you.

Best For:

  • The Auburn color is best for true auburn hair

Key Features:

  • Self-sharpening tool
  • Soft and blendable color
  • Dual-ended with a small brush
  • Available in different colors
  • Goes on very smooth

8. Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil

Check Current Price on Amazon

If you have shapeless and uneven eyebrows, then this Maybelline brow precise micro pencil is the ideal product for you. This pencil can help you fill and shape your brows naturally.

You will get precise and flawless results thanks to the 1.5-millimeter retractable tip. There’s also a short soft brush that can help you put hairs in place and fill your eyebrows flawlessly.

What we like most about this product is how it shapes the brows. You will end up with natural-looking eyebrows. The pencil is waterproof and lasts for hours. The best part? It’s affordable.

Since Maybelline is known for high-quality makeup, you can complete your look with their eyeshadows, liquid eyeliners and pencils, and mascaras. Take your eye makeup to the next level.

Their eyebrow pencil comes in different shades so you can easily find the right shade for you. It’s perfect for redheads and blondes. It’s super-versatile, budget-friendly, and easy to use.

Best For:

  • The Auburn color is best for reddish-brown hair

Key Features:

  • Easy to apply and long wear
  • The auburn color looks great for redheads
  • It works better than similar expensive pencils
  • Natural-looking, fine tip, and amazing color
  • Perfect for sparse eyebrows

For those of you with reddish-brown hair or if you’re a brunette who dyes your hair red, this Maybelline Auburn Defining Pencil review is for you!

9. Wet n Wild Color Icon Brow Pencil

Check Current Price on Amazon

As you probably know, your brows frame and define your whole face. Therefore, they require care and maintenance. Give your brows special attention with this Wet n Wild pencil.

It’s one of the best-rated eyebrow pencils on the market. This dual-ended pencil can help you shape and fill in your eyebrows with ease. It comes with a comb for perfectly groomed arches.

We like this pencil because it’s creamy, rich and lightweight. It doesn’t feel heavy on the eyebrows. You will get natural-looking eyebrows that will last for hours. It’s affordable and effective.

If you have tried everything and nothing worked for you as a redhead, consider this pencil. It’s just ideal for redheads because it’s specifically designed for individuals with light/dark red hair.

Although it’s cheap and you will have to sharpen it every day, it’s worth the trouble. The color is spot-on. It’s also easy to use, stays on and the price is great. What more could you ask for?

Best For:

  • Ginger Roots is best for golden-red hair

Key Features:

  • Budget-friendly
  • 2-in-1 dual-ended pencil for redheads
  • Rich and lightweight color that lasts all-day
  • It comes with a small grooming comb
  • Smooth and waxy

Final Thoughts

Hopefully, this list of best eyebrow pencils for redheads can help you find the right pencil. Do you have a favorite? Share your suggestions, thoughts, and questions in the comments! 

Up Next: How Long Does Makeup Last On Your Face?

You may also like

Leave a Comment