9 Best Non-Waterproof Mascaras
Everyone wants to have beautiful lashes, but not everyone is fortunate enough to have them. Thankfully, there are dozens of incredible mascaras that can darken, lengthen, curl, and thicken your lashes.
But with so many options comes overwhelm. It’s so hard to choose the right mascara when you don’t know what to look for.
There are options for everyone: waterproof, non-waterproof, natural, non-toxic, black, brown, blue, lengthening, volumizing, and more. Take your pick.
So, what are the best non-waterproof mascaras?
When it comes to waterproof or non-waterproof mascaras, there are many strong options. Some love the convenience of not worrying about smudging their mascara from humidity (or sometimes, tears), while others don’t want to deal with the somewhat difficult removal process of waterproof mascaras.
If you are in the latter group, this article is for you. Are you looking for the best non-waterproof mascara that gives you amazing lashes without damaging your natural ones? We’ve got you covered.
We’ll review all the top-rated non-waterproof mascaras currently available and provide you with everything you need to know, so you can make an informed decision.
- How To Choose The Best Non-Waterproof Mascara
- Best Non-Waterproof Mascaras
- 2. Pretty Vulgar Faux Reals Extreme Volume Mascara
- 3. Blinc UltraVolume Tubing Mascara
- 4. ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara
- 5. Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer
- 6. e.l.f. Big Mood Mascara
- 7. Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara
- 8. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
- 9. Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Washable Mascara
- Related Articles
How To Choose The Best Non-Waterproof Mascara
There are lots of factors to consider when choosing your mascara. But before we dive into them, let’s talk about why you might want a non-waterproof mascara.
Waterproof Vs. Non-Waterproof Mascara
As you can imagine, waterproof mascara has a stronger hold on your lashes and does not dissolve in water.
This can be very convenient if you’re worried about smudging your mascara while swimming, going out in the rain, or just watching a sad movie with a glass of wine (we’ve all been there).
But convenience comes with a cost. Removing waterproof mascara at the end of the night can be a hassle.
You may need special makeup removers that work on waterproof makeup to dissolve the compounds in your waterproof mascara.
As you’re trying to rub it off, you might even pull some of your lashes out – ouch! This is not ideal for you if you’re trying to have thick, healthy lashes.
Waterproof mascaras also often contain per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs), which have been linked to impaired immune function, certain cancers, and an increased risk of diabetes, obesity, and endocrine disruption, according to the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health’s Department of Environmental Health.
While the effect of waterproof mascara on one’s health is unclear, many people would rather be safe than sorry, so they opt for non-waterproof mascara.
Formula
When selecting the best non-waterproof mascaras, we focused on the formula first. Most mascaras are made with some sort of pigment and a waxy substance that coats your lashes and makes the pigment stick to them.
Some mascaras are made entirely vegan, meaning they don’t use any animal products, such as beeswax or lanolin. If that’s not important to you, then beeswax-based mascaras have great wearability.
There are many mascaras on the market that have “clean” formulas these days, meaning they don’t contain any sulfates, parabens, or fragrances that can irritate your eyes. We ensure that we include many of these cleaner formulas on our list.
We also prioritized formulas that contain eyelash-nourishing ingredients, such as castor or jojoba oil. It’s always great when your makeup can help, rather than diminish, your natural beauty.
Brush
Another important factor to consider when selecting a non-waterproof mascara is the type of brush.
The brush is what makes the mascara perform so well. Some brushes are better suited for adding length to your lashes, while others are more adept at adding thickness and volume.
Many companies also create unique brush shapes that combine these factors to offer you the best of both worlds.
When compiling our list of the best mascaras, we ensured that we paid attention to their brush types and how effectively they deliver on their promises.
Longevity
Just because you’re choosing a non-waterproof mascara, it doesn’t mean that you don’t want your mascara to stay put all day without smearing or crumbling.
We made sure to recommend mascaras that can truly last through the workday—or a night out—without letting you down.
Certain ingredients, such as silicones, help mascaras last longer and adhere better to your lashes. However, we also relied heavily on personal reviews and feedback from real users.
Based on their reviews, we selected only the best and most reliable non-waterproof mascaras that actually work.
Best Non-Waterproof Mascaras
Here are the best non-waterproof mascaras based on our research:
| Rank | Product | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Buxom Lash Volumizing Mascara | Gives you volume without clumping, contains nourishing vitamins and antioxidants |
| 2. | Pretty Vulgar Faux Reals Extreme Volume Mascara | Incredibly clean and vegan formula that gives you “faux lash” effect |
| 3. | Blinc UltraVolume Tubing Mascara | Best of tubing mascaras that give you length and volume in one swipe. Easy to wash off |
| 4. | ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara | Clean mascara that gives you length and conditions your lashes while you wear it |
| 5. | Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer | Includes primer and mascara in one tube. Clean EWG-certified formula that lengthens your lashes |
| 6. | e.l.f. Big Mood Mascara | Huge volume on a small budget |
| 7. | Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara | Gives you a very natural look while lifting and curling your lashes for the entire day |
| 8. | essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara | False lash effect on a budget - lots of length and volume at the same time |
| 9. | Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Washable Mascara | Ten-layer bristles brush that coats every single lash for a fanned-out effect |
1. Buxom Lash Volumizing Mascara
If you’re looking for incredible volume and shine, this Buxom mascara has got you covered.
Its formula is incredibly smooth and infused with glossy patent leather pigments, vitamins, and antioxidants to keep your lashes looking healthy and fierce.
Buxom has added rose water and vitamin E to its formula to help you hydrate and nourish your lashes while you’re wearing it.
Their brush is specifically designed to maximize volume. It features an hourglass shape with numerous longer and shorter bristles arranged in a way that captures every single eyelash and coats it with the thick mascara formula.
We love that despite all the volume it creates, this mascara does not produce any clumps. And it’s very easy to wash off with water and a cleanser, so you won’t be stuck rubbing and pulling your eyes at the end of the day.
2. Pretty Vulgar Faux Reals Extreme Volume Mascara
For those looking for both a clean and cruelty-free vegan formula, this Pretty Vulgar mascara has it all.
The formula is incredibly clean, featuring no fragrances, talc, gluten, oils, sulfates, or parabens, and is made with all vegan ingredients.
It’s made with synthetic beeswax and rice bran wax to maintain a strong but gentle consistency.
Its brush is soft and fluffy, featuring a subtle hourglass shape that helps add volume to the lashes. It also adds a good amount of length and overall lives up to its promise of giving you a faux lash effect.
Users love that it gives them fuller lashes without looking overdone or clumpy. Many have said they’ve stopped wearing eyeliner because this mascara is THAT good. Try it for yourself!
3. Blinc UltraVolume Tubing Mascara
Tubing mascaras are becoming all the rage, and we’re here for it. Tubing mascaras contain tube-like polymers that wrap around each individual lash, generating an enhanced lengthening effect.
There has been an influx of tubing mascaras from different brands, but this Blinc one is one of the best.
The benefits of tubing mascaras are that they give you the kind of length and lift that you can’t get from a conventional mascara unless you’re willing to spend 30 minutes every morning curling your lashes and applying several coats of product to get the desired effect.
Blinc’s UltraVolume Tubing mascara gives you an impressive faux lash look in one single swipe. If you’re looking for drama, this will provide it.
The mascara features a nice, fluffy brush that both lengthens and curls your lashes up.
The best thing about this mascara is that, despite the volume it gives you, it’s so easy to wash off. Just a little bit of warm water and gently massaging with your fingers will remove all the tubing polymers without smearing under your eyes or leaving a mess.
If you’ve never tried a tubing mascara before, definitely give this one a go!
4. ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara
ILIA mascara has a large following worldwide. First of all, it has a great, clean formula.
Made with a blend of organic beeswax and carnauba oil, it is 99% naturally derived and free from fragrances and synthetic dyes.
It’s also actually good for your lashes. ILIA has added keratin oil and shea butter to help condition and nourish your lashes while you wear it. It’s like a serum for your eyelashes that doubles as a mascara!
The brush itself features a patented design, with long bristles that comb your lashes and coat each strand separately, giving you tons of length and pigment without the dreaded “spider-legs” effect.
If you’re looking for a clean mascara that’s free from harmful chemicals and provides length and conditioning, this is a great choice.
5. Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer
This mascara is a 2-in-1 solution that comes with a lash primer. The primer helps enhance the mascara’s performance and longevity.
The formula of the mascara is infused with nourishing jojoba esters and free from parabens, paraffins, synthetic fragrances, silicones, and mineral oils.
The brush is designed to build length, and it does so well. The bristles are firm and straight, allowing you to comb through each lash while coating them with the buildable formula. This mascara doesn’t clump or make your lashes stick together.
We love that this mascara is EWG-certified, meaning it’s made with the cleanest ingredients that aren’t linked to any health issues.
The primer really helps make your lashes look long and healthy, while the nourishing pigmented formula of the mascara gives you instant runway eyes.
6. e.l.f. Big Mood Mascara
This is an award-winning mascara that fits every budget. Known for its dramatic volume, this mascara is smudge-proof and creamy.
Don’t be intimidated by the size of the brush – it’s big. But it’s made that way intentionally, to pull at every lash you have and make it pop.
Despite the size and big promises of volume, the creamy formula does a good job of never clumping, so your lashes will look great.
The Big Mood Mascara features a vegan formula that incorporates jojoba oil to nourish and condition your lashes throughout the day.
There’s a reason so many people love this mascara. If you’re looking for big volume on a small budget, this is a great option.
7. Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara
This Benefit mascara is ideal for those seeking a more natural appearance while still enhancing and awakening their eyes.
This mascara has a great formula that adds smooth length and curls your lashes up. Because it doesn’t add too much thickness, it looks very natural.
The mascara features a unique, patent-pending hook and curl brush specifically designed to gently pick each lash and curl it up while coating it with a nourishing formula.
The result? Beautiful, natural-looking, bright eyes with long, perky lashes.
One user said of this mascara, “With one coat, my lashes were to the ceiling.” We think that sums it up pretty nicely.
8. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
This mascara has recently gained popularity on TikTok, indicating that many people like it.
Designed to give you the best of both worlds – length and volume – this mascara features a fluffy, slightly cone-shaped brush that coats every single lash in its rich formula while providing it with lift and length.
Most users agree that it lasts all day without flaking or smudging, and gives their lashes a dramatic look.
We like the formula because it’s vegan and cruelty-free; however, it does not contain any lash-nourishing ingredients like some of the other mascaras on our list. That being said, it’s a great mascara for those looking for good performance on a budget.
9. Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Washable Mascara
If you want to elongate, separate, and fan out your lashes, look no further than this Maybelline mascara. It’s been around for a while, and it’s only gotten more popular with time, thanks to its unique brush and solid formulation.
The brush was designed specifically to fit most eye shapes. It consists of ten layers of bristles, ensuring that each lash is coated and separated, which gives you a fanned-out effect.
The brush allows this mascara to work well for everyone. Short lashes, long lashes, unruly lashes, straight lashes, and sparse lashes… every lash out there will get longer, thicker, and curled by this wand.
The only downside is that this mascara is not vegan or particularly “clean”, but it works well and gives you incredible lashes at an affordable price.
Related Articles
Does Mascara Make Your Eyelashes Longer?
