Home Skincare 5 Best Eye Creams For Eyelash Extensions

5 Best Eye Creams For Eyelash Extensions

by Gabbi

When you spend your time and money getting some gorgeous eyelash extensions done, you want to make sure that you use the right products to not ruin the extensions.

There are so many different types of eye creams on the market, you need to choose the right one which will not interfere with your eyelashes. There are some eye creams that are suitable to use for eyelash extensions and others that should be avoided.

Which are the best eye creams for eyelash extensions? The best eye creams for eyelash extensions are water-based and not oil-based. Oil-based eye creams can cause build-up and irritation and might ruin eyelash extensions. Water-based eye creams are light and safe to use. Eye gels are often better oil-free choices.

You may find it is actually better to just use eye gels, as eye creams are more likely to contain a high oil content, whereas gels tend to have a higher water content. But you can still go for water-based eye creams when you find them.

To help you choose the best eye cream to use for eyelash extensions, we have listed what to look for, and the best creams for you to use!

How To Choose Eye Cream For Eyelash Extensions

You do need to spend some time finding the right eye creams to use if you have eyelash extensions. It needs to be the right product that will not interfere with your extensions, or cause them to not last as long as they should.

If you do not know what to look for, here are some considerations to keep in mind when choosing the right eye creams.


The eye cream you choose to use when you have eyelash extensions should not be oil-based. Oil-based creams tend to be heavy and can leave a deposit of oil and product under your eyes. This could transfer to your lash extensions, causing them to clog up and not last long enough.

The oil in the cream might also interfere with the glue of the lash extensions, and you might notice the lashes falling off way before they are supposed to.

Instead of oil-based creams, look for light, water-based creams that will not leave a residue or wash away the lash extension glue.

Vitamins & Minerals

The whole point of eye cream is to provide the skin around your eyes with the proper nourishment and care.

Make sure to check that the eye cream you are interested in has all the right nutrients and vitamins to keep your skin soft and nourished.

Natural Ingredients

It is always better to use natural products. Heavy chemicals could cause irritation and might interfere with the lash glue or cause build-up on the lashes themselves.

Try to choose an eye cream that is as natural as possible; these also tend to have the most nutrients!

Skin Type

The eye cream you choose must be suitable for your specific skin type. There is no point in buying an eye cream suited for dry skin if your skin is generally oily. Make sure to look for eye cream suited for sensitive skin if you suffer from breakouts and irritation.

5 Best Eye Creams For Eyelash Extensions

Here are the best eye creams for eyelash extensions:

RankProductKey Features
1.Best Eye Creams For Eyelash ExtensionsAnti-aging, peptides, wrinkle reducing
2.Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel CreamNon-comedogenic, fragrance-free, good for dry skin
3.LilyAna Naturals Eye CreamNatural, vegan ingredients; good for all skin types
4.Cetaphil Deep Hydration Refreshing Eye SerumIdeal for dry and sensitive skin, long-lasting
5.Feulover Anti-Aging Eye CreamFirms and lifts skin while hydrating, absorbs quickly
BonusNeutrogena Oil-Free Facial MoisturizerGood for sensitive skin, can be applied to face and neck

These are safe to use while wearing eyelash extensions and they will not interfere with the glue or lashes themselves. This means you can wear your lashes for longer while enjoying the nutrients and care that eye cream will give!

1. EltaMD Renew Eye Gel

Check Current Price On Amazon

If your main goal is reducing and preventing fine lines and wrinkles, you won’t want to pass on this dermatologist-recommended brand for your perfect eye gel.

Completely oil free and full of beneficial peptides and hydrating ingredients, this gel will keep your eyes looking lifted, youthful, and radiant.

Not only does it reduce the appearance of wrinkles, but it also gets rid of dark circles, under eye puffiness, and dryness.

This formula also includes hyaluronic acid to help your skin gain and retain moisture all day. Over time, you’ll begin to notice the skin around your eyes is much brighter and healthier looking than before.

So, what are you waiting for? Start your journey to youthful skin today!

1. Neutrogena Hydro Boost Eye Gel Cream

Check Current Price On Amazon

The Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Gel Eye Cream is made with purified hyaluronic acid, which is naturally found in the skin, but which fades away over time. This means your skin will have access to this nutrient, helping it prevent dryness and stay hydrated.

The eye gel will also work to cleanse your skin of makeup and dirt and keep away a buildup of oil and chemicals.  The toner and serum formula helps to prep and treat your eye area, making sure to be gentle and caring.

For an extra boost of hydration, the Neutrogena Hydro Boost Gel is water-based, and will not interfere with your lash extensions.

This moisturizer will protect your sensitive eye skin with added moisture on its own or underneath your makeup, keeping it in the most hydrated condition possible.

2. LilyAna Naturals Eye Cream

Check Current Price On Amazon

This All-In-One eye cream absorbs into the skin quickly to rejuvenate the delicate eye area, to give a youthful, lifted look, without interfering or damaging your eyelash extensions.

Using an advanced botanical formula, the light yet nourishing cream pampers and protects delicate skin, using a careful blend of nutrients and antioxidants. Some of the caring ingredients include vitamin E, Provitamin A, and B5, as well as Rosehip Seed Oil, Rosemary Leaf Extract, and Hibiscus Flower.

You will benefit from complete anti-aging benefits from this eye cream, both day and night. With added protection to protect against aging, the eye cream also reduces dark circles, loss of firmness, sagging skin, and dryness.

It is suitable for all skin types, and is completely safe to use with your gorgeous lash extensions!

3. Cetaphil Deep Hydration Refreshing Eye Serum

Check Current Price On Amazon

Cetaphil offers a deeply hydrating treatment with this refreshing eye serum. With exclusive HydroSensitive Complex, it helps to provide dynamic hydration to smooth and soothe skin sensitivity.

The eye cream works to deeply replenish your skin’s hydration, with a targeted action to rehydrate the sensitive area to prevent dryness. This also helps to reduce fine lines and improves the quality of sensitive skin over time.

Most importantly, the cream is fine to use with eyelash extensions. Enjoy your eyelash extensions more with the reduced dark circles and reduced puffiness that this cream provides. You are also able to use the applicator tip to provide a gentle massage under your eyes to reinvigorate your skin.

Designed to be used for sensitive skin, the eye cream will not irritate your skin, and will keep your lash extensions in stunning condition along with your skin!

4. Feulover Anti-Aging Eye Cream

Check Current Price On Amazon

Made with anti-aging properties, this eye cream effectively reduces dark circles, fine lines, and puffiness. The skin under your eyes will look youthful and smooth, to match your new lash extensions!

Containing natural plant extracts, the cream provides hydrating effects, reducing the look of tiredness, and gives you a more refreshed appearance.

The light texture of the cream absorbs into the skin easily, and will not leave any buildup on your lashes or interfere with the lash glue. It does not contain any harsh chemicals and is suitable for all skin types. To achieve the most youthful look, use this eye cream twice a day!

5. Neutrogena Oil-Free Facial Moisturizer

Check Current Price On Amazon

This gentle formula is ideal to use under your eyes, and as it contains no harsh chemicals, the cream will not have an effect on your eyelash extensions and will leave them looking stunning for a longer period of time.

Specially formulated for sensitive skin, the moisturizer is oil-free and lightweight. It is ultra-gentle on the skin and can be used on all skin types.

Made with a water-based formula, vitamins, nutrients, and natural ingredients, your skin will be left nourished, hydrated, and youthful-looking.

The cream can be applied to your skin morning and evening and can be used on its own or under makeup.

Related Questions

How Do I Clean My Eyes After Eyelash Extensions?

If you have worn makeup and want to remove it, but are nervous that you might damage your eyelash extensions, don’t worry. You can remove makeup with no problem; just do so carefully.

Remove any makeup using warm water, or an oil-free makeup remover.

It is important to be sure that your makeup remover truly does not have any added oil, as this could cause the lashes to become gunked up or loose.

Can I Use Baby Shampoo to Clean Eyelash Extensions?

You can use baby shampoo to clean your eyelash extensions, as long as it is an oil-free shampoo. You also need to be sure that the baby shampoo will not dry them out.

It is better however to use a cleanser that was made specifically for eyelash extensions, as these will be gentler and safer to use.

Can I Use Johnson’s Baby Shampoo For My Lashes?

Do not use Johnson’s Baby Shampoo for your eyelash extensions. It contains fragrance, colors, and mineral oils. These can interfere with your eyelash extensions and damage them.

It is always better to use a shampoo made for eyelash extensions, to extend their lifespan further.

Eye Cream For Eyelash Extensions – Review

You need to be so careful with the eye cream you use when you have eyelash extensions. If you use an oil-based eye cream, your lashes could form a buildup, and the oil could interfere with the lash glue. This could have a damaging effect on how long your lashes last!

It is best to use a water-based eye cream, which will be nourishing and gentle on your skin, but which will not damage your eyelash extensions. Choose one that helps remove puffiness and dark circles, so that your stunning eyelash extensions really shine!

Up Next: Can You Sleep With Magnetic Lashes?

You may also like

Leave a Comment