9 Best Drunk Elephant Dupes (Protini, C-Firma, Lala)
Drunk Elephant built a whole brand on the idea that you should be able to read the label, and then priced the label out of most people’s reach.
Protini, C-Firma and Lala Retro are the three that people ask about most, and they are also the three that are easiest to replace.
So what are the best Drunk Elephant dupes? They are products that copy the working part of the formula, not the packaging. A peptide cream for Protini, an L-ascorbic acid serum with ferulic acid and vitamin E for C-Firma, and a whipped barrier cream for Lala Retro.
Every product below is in stock, sold by whoever holds the buy box, and rated at least 4.2 stars across 500 or more reviews. I have grouped them by which Drunk Elephant product they stand in for.
Quick picks
| Dupe | Stands in for | Best for | Where to buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Naturium Multi-Peptide Moisturizer | Protini | The closest match to Protini | Check it on Amazon |
| Olay Collagen Peptide Face Moisturizer | Protini | Drugstore, fragrance-free | Check it on Amazon |
| e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Face Cream | Protini | The cheapest way in | Check it on Amazon |
| Timeless Vitamin C Serum with Vitamin E and Ferulic Acid | C-Firma | The long-running C-Firma stand-in | Check it on Amazon |
| MAELOVE Glow Maker Vitamin C Serum | C-Firma | Best texture of the vitamin C picks | Check it on Amazon |
| Geek and Gorgeous C-Glow | C-Firma | Oily skin, water-light finish | Check it on Amazon |
| Thayers Barrier Bestie Ultra Whip Face Cream | Lala Retro | The real texture match for Lala Retro | Check it on Amazon |
| Holika Holika Good Cera Super Ceramide Cream | Lala Retro | Dry, tight, winter skin | Check it on Amazon |
| COSRX 7X Ceramide Moisturizer | Lala Retro | Most product in the jar | Check it on Amazon |
What makes a real Drunk Elephant dupe
Most lists of Drunk Elephant dupes are lists of products in similar jars. That is not the same thing.
Here is what I actually checked for:
- The active that does the work is present, and present high enough in the ingredient list to matter.
- No added fragrance or essential oils, since avoiding those is most of the reason people buy Drunk Elephant in the first place.
- A rating of at least 4.2 stars across 500 or more reviews, checked on the listing today rather than pulled from an old roundup.
- Currently in stock with a working buy box.
That last one knocked out more candidates than anything else. Skincare dupe articles rot fast, and half the products people still recommend are dead listings.
It is the same test I used on the Skinceuticals Triple Lipid Restore dupes, and on the Pureology dupes over on the hair side.
Best Protini Polypeptide Cream dupes
Protini is a peptide moisturizer, so a dupe has to lead with peptides. A cream that is mostly hyaluronic acid with one peptide at the bottom of the list is a different product wearing the same outfit.
1. Naturium Multi-Peptide Moisturizer
It sits at 4.6 stars across 2,038 reviews.
This is the one I would hand somebody who liked Protini and wants the same job done for less.
It runs on a peptide blend with vitamin C and panthenol, and it comes in the same 1.7 ounce size, so the comparison is easy to make.
The texture is a little richer than Protini. If you have oily skin you may want it at night only.
2. Olay Collagen Peptide Face Moisturizer
It sits at 4.5 stars across 3,963 reviews.
Peptides and niacinamide, no fragrance, sold in every drugstore in the country.
Olay has been doing peptide moisturizers longer than most of the brands charging four times as much for them.
This is the pick for anyone who wants firmer skin without a routine built around one hero jar.
3. e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Face Cream
It sits at 4.6 stars across 21,688 reviews.
Hyaluronic acid, niacinamide and peptides in a whipped gel cream that sinks in fast.
At nearly 22,000 reviews it is the most publicly tested cream on this list by a wide margin.
It is lighter than Protini rather than a texture match, which makes it the better summer option of the three.
Best C-Firma Fresh Day Serum dupes
C-Firma is the easiest of the three to replace, because the formula it is built on is public. L-ascorbic acid, ferulic acid and vitamin E is a combination that has been in dermatology papers since the 1990s, and a dozen brands make a version of it.
What you are really shopping for here is percentage and packaging.
4. Timeless Vitamin C Serum with Vitamin E and Ferulic Acid
It sits at 4.3 stars across 13,370 reviews.
Same three actives as C-Firma, same fragrance-free approach, one ounce bottle.
People have been buying this instead of expensive vitamin C serums for well over a decade, which is why the review count is where it is.
It oxidizes like every L-ascorbic acid serum does. Keep it out of the sun and use it up rather than saving it for special occasions.
5. MAELOVE Glow Maker Vitamin C Serum
It sits at 4.3 stars across 1,247 reviews.
Vitamin C with vitamin E and ferulic acid, plus hyaluronic acid to take the edge off.
This is the one that layers best under makeup. It does not pill and it does not leave the tacky film that C-Firma can leave on some skin.
6. Geek and Gorgeous C-Glow
It sits at 4.3 stars across 2,063 reviews.
Fifteen percent vitamin C with ferulic acid and vitamin E, in a formula that is closer to water than serum.
If thick vitamin C serums make you break out, start here.
The brand publishes its percentages on the front of the bottle, which is rarer than it should be.
Best Lala Retro Whipped Cream dupes
Lala Retro is the hardest to match, because half of what people like about it is the whipped texture rather than the ingredient list.
So I split the difference. One texture match, and two ceramide creams that do the barrier repair job better than Lala Retro does.
If you also screen for silicones, check the labels against the silicone free moisturizers roundup before you buy.
7. Thayers Barrier Bestie Ultra Whip Face Cream
It sits at 4.4 stars across 646 reviews.
Of everything I looked at, this is the one that actually feels like Lala Retro going on.
It is whipped rather than dense, and it runs on sugarcane squalane and ceramides instead of the African oil blend.
Smallest review count on this list at 646, so it is the newest pick here. The rating has held at 4.4 as those reviews came in.
8. Holika Holika Good Cera Super Ceramide Cream
It sits at 4.6 stars across 1,252 reviews.
A ceramide cream that sits somewhere between a moisturizer and a sleeping mask.
Buy this one if your skin gets tight and flaky in the cold and Lala Retro was the only thing that fixed it.
9. COSRX 7X Ceramide Moisturizer
It sits at 4.7 stars across 1,180 reviews.
Seven ceramides, built for a barrier that has been pushed too hard by acids or retinoids.
The 2.7 ounce tub is the biggest on this list, so it is the one to buy if you also want it on your neck and hands.
Highest rated pick here at 4.7 stars.
What to skip
Skip any vitamin C serum that will not tell you its percentage. If the brand is proud of the formula it goes on the front of the bottle.
Skip the marbled, brightly capped bottles that look like Drunk Elephant and say nothing about what is inside. Copying the packaging is cheaper than copying the formula, and plenty of sellers have worked that out.
And skip buying a vitamin C serum in bulk. It oxidizes whether you open it or not.
Related questions
Is there an exact dupe for Protini?
No. The peptide blend in Protini is proprietary, so nothing on the market matches it ingredient for ingredient. The Naturium Multi-Peptide Moisturizer gets closest on both the peptide content and the texture.
Why is C-Firma so easy to dupe?
Because the formula it is based on is not a secret. L-ascorbic acid with ferulic acid and vitamin E is a published, widely copied combination, and any brand can make a version of it.
Can I use a dupe of all three together?
Yes, and the order is the same as it would be with the originals. Vitamin C serum on clean skin in the morning, then a moisturizer on top. Save the richer creams for night if your skin runs oily.
If you want a hydrating step between the two, a hyaluronic acid toner goes on damp skin before the serum.
Do cheaper dupes work as well?
For C-Firma and Lala Retro, yes, and in the case of the ceramide creams I think the dupes are better. Protini is the one where the original still has an edge, mostly on how it feels rather than what it does.
Related articles
- 7 Best Skinceuticals Triple Lipid Restore Dupes
- 7 Best Pureology Dupes
- Best Silicone Free Moisturizers
- Best Hyaluronic Acid Toners
- Best Face Washes For Dark Spots And Hyperpigmentation
